World’s Most Beautiful, Nation’s Most Miserable?

Forbes can’t seem to keep Chicago out of its “America’s Most Miserable Cities” top ten list. At least we dropped to tenth place this year, as opposed to third last year. Yet, when I see places like Canton, Ohio on the list, I can’t help but wonder. Canton’s so small that I wouldn’t think it would even be in the running, not to mention the fact that, well, Ohio has several cities in almost exactly the same situation as Canton; honestly, many Midwestern cities have been facing the shrinking syndrome, and the recession only helped to exacerbate the urban break-down. Most of them make the top twenty (Forbes listed Toledo, Akron, and Youngstown), but I'm surprised to see Canton so high on the list. And to see Cleveland at the top, ahead of Detroit…shocking.

Of course, how do you really measure the "misery" of one city against another? And I question Forbes. Case in point: Forbes declares Chicago the nation’s tenth most miserable city today; yet, less than a month ago, they named Chicago to their list of the “World’s Most Beautiful Cities.” Most Miserable and Most Beautiful? To me, this is contradictory (are homelessness and crime and congested traffic beautiful?). I’m willing to bet that Forbes only publishes these things to drive traffic to their site anyway. And really, I can’t blame them. It works.

In a city like Chicago, where outsiders look in on the frigid winters, crowded roadways, political corruption, and crime, and shiver, most people on the inside will still tell you how much there is to love about this place. The winters are harsh, yes, but then summer hits and it feels luxurious. And public transportation (even if it has its problems), or Lake Shore Drive, allows you to bypass bumper-to-bumper traffic. Then of course there’s the architecture, the events, the culture, the foood…

True, Chicago is far from perfect. And I do not wish to poo-poo the level of crime and homelessness that exist here. We certainly have our problems. Yet, there is also much to love about Chicago (though I realize that you have to be in a position economically to enjoy much of it). The pride in this city is quite astounding (as an example, look at how people continue to support the Cubs and the Bears). If it were so miserable, I’m pretty sure there wouldn’t be over three million people living here, and more clamoring to get here everyday.

Check out this slideshow from the Chicago Tribune, for some pieces of what's not miserable about Chicago.

***

This post has been updated several times. I did a little more digging into the Forbes list, and changed my original assertions a little bit. Oh, and I had some spirited discussion with friends through Facebook that made me realize there were some key factors missing from my post. :)

Thank You, Craigslist, the Modern Newspaper

In the opening pages of Devil in the White City, Larson’s narrator describes Chicago as both a liberating and precarious opportunity for women in the late 19th century. (This resonates with me on a variety of levels, but I’ll save you the literary and feminist theory.) I was struck by the following warning for ladies that Larson quotes from the March 30, 1890 Chicago Tribune: “[N]o thoroughly honorable business-man who is this side of dotage ever advertises for a lady stenographer who is blonde, is good-looking, is quite alone in the city, or will telegraph her photograph. All such advertisements upon their face bear the marks of vulgarity…” The reason this struck me is because you’ll find exactly the same thing on Craigslist today, and, I bet, unsuspecting women still respond.

I recall trolling through the employment pages of Craigslist Chicago throughout summer 2008, and for much of spring 2009, reading very similar postings, playing themselves off as legitimate employment ads: I would read them aloud to my friends for a laugh. Under the office/admin category, men would post ads for young women who were “good-looking” to fill a personal assistant position, and part of the application requirements stated, “Must include photograph.” Now, we all know there are certain areas of Craigslist where you’d expect to find something like this, but I guess I was surprised to find them masquerading as something legitimate. I just feel badly for any young woman who unsuspectingly applied and interviewed for one of those positions.

When I first started using Craigslist, I was fairly naïve, myself. The site is pretty much useless if you don’t have a sizeable population that’s actually going to use it. So, I didn’t really know much about it before I started using the site to find jobs in Chicago. Yet, if it weren’t for Craigslist, I most likely would not be where I am now. I did not come across the posting for my 6-month internship on any other sites; in fact, the line of business was a bit different from anything I’d ever really contemplated. But I found it on Craigslist, applied, and ta-da, I was moving to Chicago to work for a big corporation. But not before finding roommates--through Craigslist, of course. I met my future roommates when I came to interview, and I was comfortable with them and their home (so comfortable that I didn’t meet with any of my other Craigslist possibilities), and had no problem moving in two weeks later. In fact, I never had a problem with my Craigslist roommates at all.

When my internship was ending in the spring, and I started job hunting again, Craigslist had been thoroughly infiltrated with scammers (I hadn’t noticed it being as much the summer before). Well aware of the hardships faced by so many Americans during the recession, many posts would prey on desperate job-seekers, directing them to other sites to try and gather personal information, or tricking them into scam jobs (like my friend Jess who handed out The Printed Blog for hours one evening and then went to pick up her paycheck and they made up an excuse not to pay her.) I finally learned not to include any personal information on my resume, other than an email address for contact, unless I could find a legitimate company website through which to apply, or the company responded to me and, in some legitimate way, identified themselves. There are a lot of honest people on Craigslist, but, as in reality, there are plenty of ill-intentioned souls lurking there, too.

I like living in a place where people actually use the site, even if you do have to be cautious about how you use it. I actually owe Craigslist quite a bit, and I feel like it’s an integral part of city life, particularly for those who live on a budget, because the site is loaded with deals. If I’m looking for used furniture, or freebies, or even a date, I can go there. That last part was a joke; I do, however, know some women who have met guys through Craigslist, but that, to me, is scarier than interviewing for one of those sleazy ads for a leggy young chick.

I read in the news recently that Craigslist encompasses the simplicity for which newspapers strive but can’t achieve, and that the secret to that simplicity—and the site’s success—is that its creators didn’t care about making a profit (here’s an article from Boing Boing that will insert you into that discussion.) I feel like Craigslist really does encapsulate the simplicity of early newspapers. You’ve got your classifieds, your job postings, your personals, your humor/advice/opinions (Missed Connections, Rants and Raves), your apartment-hunting. All you’re missing is news. And what makes Craigslist better than a newspaper is the fact that there’s a search box in every category: minimum energy, maximum reward. And as much as I don’t want to see print newspapers go extinct, I won’t be giving up Craigslist anytime soon.